Does wine vintage matter?
While the reasons may be different depending on if you are a serious collector, a wine dabbler, or someone who buys wine to drink right away, the answer is “YES”.
Wine vintage matters.
The quality, quantity, and flavor profile of wine can vary greatly from year to year, vintage to vintage.
Some wine vintages are just better than others. And, for collectors, some wine vintages can be aged longer than others.
Why is one year different than another?
Remember that wineries are in the agriculture business. The vineyards are the farms and grapes are the crops. Magical, wonderful crops.
As farmers, wine growers are at the mercy of weather and climate. Too much rain – no good. Too little rain – no good. The same can be said for heat. And coolness and fog.
Each of these things – factors that only Mother Nature controls – can make or break a wine vintage.
Throw in things like earthquakes, forest fires, fungus, parasites and disease and you have to imagine that winemakers and vineyard managers must do a whole lot of worrying. And praying.
Vineyard managers and winemakers are in the field every day checking on their crops and doing whatever they can to overcome the challenges thrown at them by Mother Nature.
And they do it all for us so that we can enjoy the delicious nectar of the vine.
Why do I care if I plan to drink my wine right away?
Studies show that 80 – 90% of wine purchased is consumed within 24 hours. And 90 – 95% is consumed within a week.
So why does wine vintage matter if you are not going to keep the bottle for very long?
Because some vintages are simply better than others. Going to the store armed with a little bit of knowledge can make all the difference in how much you enjoy the wine you purchase.
Do yourself a favor and check out this super-helpful vintage chart from Wine Enthusiast.
Let’s take the example of a Cabernet Sauvignon from Napa.
According to the Wine Enthusiast chart, the Napa Cabernet vintage of 2011 is rated 89 while the 2012 and 2013 vintages are rated 95. Quite the difference, eh?
When you are in the grocery store picking up a bottle of wine for tonight’s dinner, you might look at the vast number of choices and have no idea where to start. Maybe you don’t recognize any of the wineries or you want to try something new.
First, you narrow down the choices based on price point. Next, perhaps you pick out a few based on the wine label (38% of wine buyers do).
But what next? How do you make the final selection?
Wine vintage, of course.
Again, let’s use Napa Cabernet as an example.You will likely see some 2011s, some 2012s and some 2013s on the shelf.
We know the 2011 is out. Both the 2012 and 2013 are rated the same and will be great. But, if presented with both, I’d go with the 2012 because it has had a chance to age a bit just relaxing there in the bottle on the shelf.
The same rule applies if you are out to dinner and ordering a glass or bottle of wine. Given the choice, pick the better vintage. And the older vintage as long as you know it is of equal quality.
But be absolutely certain that you are served the vintage you selected. Sometimes restaurants are slow to update their wine menu when they run out of a vintage.
And, by the way, watch out for this when looking at “shelf talkers” at your wine store.
Shelf talkers are the little cards hanging from the shelf showing recommendations and noting high scores. If the shelf talker says that the 2012 Blah Blah Cabernet is rated a 95, be sure that it is the 2012 Blah Blah Cabernet you are buying.
Wine vintage matters.
And what about those who hold bottles longer?
If you are someone who wants to stock up on wine to save for a little bit of time or for serious aging, you will want to focus on the best vintages.
You are going to want to search out Napa Cabernet from 2005, 2007, 2012 and 2013 rather than from 2011.
Sidenote: Even though it was a tougher wine vintage, that’s not to say that all 2011’s are inferior. We have some bottles from that vintage in our cellar. But, we only have wines from winemakers we know and trust. It was a challenging year, for sure, but not impossible.
In addition to affecting the quality, wine vintage can also affect the ageability.
The Wine Enthusiast chart has a nifty color-coded system that shows if a wine is past its prime or right in the sweet spot for drinking.
Wine vintages that show up as “Hold” can certainly be consumed now if you want. The “Hold” designation just means that the wine will get even better with age.
The ageablity information helps collectors keep track of when wines should be consumed. You certainly wouldn’t want to invest in a fabulous bottle of wine from an excellent vintage only to stash it away for too long and miss the peak flavor.
That’s what we call a wine collector’s/first world problem/gut-wrenching nightmare.
As with everything, knowledge is power. Bookmark this post and download the Wine Enthusiast vintage chart to help with your wine purchasing choices. You will be glad you did!
Cheers!Thanks for stopping by,
You Might Also Like: